This elimination table is up to date as of BFMC 40A.
| Contestant | Team | Placed | Elimination/Rejoin Episode | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lighter - Alexander Rector | None | Candy, Ping Pong Ball, Propeller Hat, Soap, and Badge all rejoin later, and don't have a place. The rest placed 75th-68th | 1B | DNP - Auto-eliminated |
| Melony - Kobe Fish | None | |||
| Pearly - Sandi Wescott | None | |||
| Ping Pong Ball - ConskiHogan | None | |||
| Tissue - Enzo S.S | None | |||
| Candy - Dahila DaWitch | None | |||
| Locky - TheGkanderson77 | None | |||
| Tissues - Daniel Webb | None | |||
| Soap - Kalini Houdini | None | |||
| Nickel - BlasteroidBob21 | None | |||
| Atlas - Joe Ferbian | None | |||
| Propeller Hat - WhaiJay | None | |||
| Badge - DeeandEd | None | |||
| Ping Pong Ball - ConskiHogan | Marisa | Rejoins | 2A | Commented on video; Playing as PPB |
| Television - Nicholas Logan | Marisa | 67th-65th | 3A | Didn't do the challenge |
| Rubix Cube - sonicplaysminecraft | Sakuya | Fan and USB's immunity | ||
| Boxing Glove - Lucas Brazil | Sanae | Unpopularity | ||
| Top Hat - BFMCTop Hat | Marisa | (No place. Rejoins later) | 4A | Did the worst, out of everyone on the Marisa tribe |
| Marble - MrAndrewtb | Yuyuko | (No place. Rejoins later) | Retro made a slip-up, and veteran support for Coiny | |
| Knife - misterperfectawesome | Patchouli | 64th | DNP; Unpopular | |
| Badge - DeeandEd | Marisa | Rejoins | 4A | Active in other camps; Popular; Chosen by Naz, although Retro made the episode |
| Soap - Kalini Houdini | Yuyuko | Rejoins | ||
| Propeller Hat - WhaiJay | Patchouli | Rejoins | ||
| Tiki - SmithchadsPantz | Yuyuko | 63rd | 4B | Retro fixing his slip-up; Tiki originally would have been out due to being a floater. |
| Marble - MrAndrewtb | Yuyuko | Rejoins | 4B | Retro fixing his slip-up |
| Cherry - Alex Coffey | Marisa | 62nd-60th | 5A | Unpopular |
| Fan - TheRedBreloom | Sakuya | Didn't do last challenge | ||
| Microphone - lorri peterman | Patchouli | Unpopular; Floater | ||
| Snowball - TardisTheTardis | Reimu | (No place. Rejoins later) | 6A | Mii U used his IT, saving himself, and then RT saved himself with the WT. |
| Popcorn - B Beatsman | Sakuya | 59th/58th | Trophy's WT | |
| Butter - John Smith | Yuyuko | Unpopular | ||
| Mii U - objectville | Reimu | 57th/56th | 7A | Saving himself from elimination last time wasn't a good sign, and he was not as popular as the rest |
| Coney - MegaEpicFilmz | Patchouli | Floater | ||
| Trophy - dhs spivak | Sakuya | (No place. Rejoins later) | Unpopular character; Saved himself from elimination last time | |
| Ping Pong Ball - ConskiHogan | Marisa | 55th | 8A | Rejoiner; Unpopular user |
| Globe - SuperNinBFDI | Sanae | (No place. Rejoins later) | Floater | |
| Soap - Kalini Houdini | Yuyuko | Quit; Got a low score | ||
| Picture - theyoylecakestudios | Reimu | 54th/53rd | 9A | Not-as-popular |
| Whistle - NINJAxxSNIPER | Marisa | (No place. Rejoins later) | Didn't participate | |
| Cheesy - Spongy317 | Patchouli | 54th/53rd | Didn't participate | |
| USB - Nathanael Cameron | Sakuya | 52nd | 10A | Unpopular |
| Snowball - TardisTheTardis | Cirno | Rejoins | 10A | Popularity |
| Candy - Dahila DaWitch | Suwako | Popularity | ||
| Trophy - dhs spivak | Suwako | Popularity | ||
| Toothy - blade theblade | Cirno | 51st | 10B | Tagged by Disc, then Paper Airplane twice (Auto-eliminated) |
| Dusty - theelementalraccoon | Cirno | (No place. Rejoins later) | Tagged by Badge, Milk, then Book (Auto-eliminated) | |
| Book - jay28jay2 | Suwako | 50th | Tagged by Marble at the start, then RT twice, RT delivering the last tag (How interesting, she got the first and last tag) (Auto-eliminated) | |
| Flower - Retro Guy | Suwako | Debuts | 10B | Quit as host, but became a contestant |
| Pin - PowerPointninja | Cirno | Debuts | 11A | Did the best in the debut |
| BFMC - pokpower8 | Cirno | Debuts | ||
| Rocky - JCL Kaytwo | None | Debuts | 11B | Selected to debut |
| Cat Bed - Reviloja2 | Cirno | Debuts | 12A | Selected to debut |
| Fries - Cody Nutt | Cirno | Debuts | Selected to debut | |
| Rocky - JCL Kaytwo | None | 49.5th | Quit to bring back Top Hat (Either his brother or a character change, according to many). Later banned for a year along with Top Hat | |
| Top Hat - BFMCTop Hat | Cirno | Rejoins | Rocky quit to bring him back | |
| Pen - Hunter Jaye | Cirno | Debuts | Selected to debut | |
| Ice Cube - DarkSid3Gam3r | Suwako | Debuts | Selected to debut | |
| OJ - Supercool16 | Suwako | Debuts | Selected to debut | |
| Lightbulb - Brandon D | Cirno | Debuts | 12B | Selected to debut |
| Gelatin - Nicholas Sternes | Cirno | Debuts | Selected to debut | |
| Paper Airplane - ThatJRP14 | Suwako | (No place. Rejoins later) | 12C | Paper Airplane quits and allows Dusty to come back in the game |
| Dusty - Theelementalraccoon | Suwako | Rejoins | ||
| Top Hat - BFMCTop Hat | Cirno | 49th | 13A | Banned by Nazriniator for 1 year for videos of proof of him being JCL Kaytwo. Aswell as to prevent more flamewars involving him. |
| Fries - Cody Nutt | Cirno | (No place. Rejoins later) | 14A | Badge would have been eliminated for not doing the challenge, but he actually did do the challenge. This eliminated Fries, the other contestant in the Bottom 2. |
| Soccer Ball - KnifetheBeast | Suwako | 48th | 15A | Didn't do the challenge |
| Yin Yang - Cpinkman3 | Cirno | (No place. Rejoins later) | 15B | Quits because of hard challenges |
| Fries - Cody Nutt | Cirno | Rejoins | Yin Yang quits, allowing Fries to rejoin. | |
| Clock - Ni Hao Guylan | Suwako | (No place. Rejoins later) | 16A | Gelatin rigging votes, and the alliance giving him likes in order to be saved. |
| Trophy - dhspivak | Suwako | 47th | 17A | Gelatin's End Token cut off voting early. |
| Fries - Cody Nutt | Cirno | 46th | 18A | Unknown, possibly for being a debuter. |
| Paintbrush - Supercool16 | Suwako | 45th | 19A | Possibly for debuting. Real reason unknown. |
| Boombox - john zhao | Suwako | 44th | 20A | His user was the least popular, out of everyone, and he used a Win Token instead of an Immunity Token. |
| Coiny - TheOnlyBoxThatSubs | Sanae-Yuyuko | 43rd | 21A | Coiny was eliminated by Pencil and Pen's Win and Immunity tokens, respectively, and did not use either of his tokens, as each of them could have saved him from elimination. |
| Marble - MrAndrewtb | Sanae 2.0 | 42nd | 22A | Marble hasn't done much challenges lately. His Reversal Token's effects on Golf Ball's token failed to save him. |
| Badge - DeeandEd | Marisa 2.1 | (No place. Rejoins later) | 23A | Targeted as a threat |
| Portal Gun - SirenRabbid1687 | Marisa 2.1 | 41st | 24A | Targeted as a threat, Did not do the challange. |
| Propeller Hat - WhaiJay | New Sweet Blueberriess | (No Place. Becomes uneliminated) | 25A | Didn't do the challenge, Gelatin's End Token. |
| Gelatin - Nicholas Sternes | 40th | Caused Controversy when Clock was eliminated, rigged votes, and was eliminated by his own End Token. Was later banned for rigging votes. | ||
| Pencil - Ben1178 | (No Place. Becomes uneliminated) | Threat, Gelatin's End Token. | ||
| Pencil - Ben1178 | New Sweet Blueberries | Uneliminated | 25B | Received enough votes to be safe |
| Propeller Hat - Whaijay | ||||
| Cat Bed - Reviloja2 | New Sweet Blueberries | (No place. Rejoins later) | 26A | Accused of betraying his alliance aswell as Flower convincing some people to vote him off. Also, this was his first time UFE, possibly making others think he's sort of a threat. |
| Tetris Block - YearsAnimations | New Sour Lemons | (No place. Rejoins later) | 27A | Quits due to controversies and fights in BFMC |
| Reversal Token - KirbyRider1337 | New Sweet Blueberries | (No place. Rejoins later) | 27B | Quits due to two contestants teaming up on him (One actually trying to frame him by editing this very table) |
| Whistle - NINJAxxSNIPER | Rejoins | Reversal Token selected him to rejoin due to user friendship. There were so many others Reversal Token could have chosen, aside from Whistle himself. | ||
| Fly Swat - MatrVincent | New Sour Lemons | (No place. Rejoins later) | 28A | Fly Swat was a threat, but would have been safe if it wasn't for Sunglasses' WT. |
| Badge - DeeandEd | New Sweet Blueberries | Rejoins | 28B | One of the people who did the challenge, and he was also selected to rejoin to make up for the 23A controversy. |
| Clock - Ni Hao Guylan | New Sour Lemons | Rejoins | 29A | Popularity |
| Match - Ben1178 | N/A | Debuts | 29B | Years let her back in because her user had very good reasons to get XQZ'd, even three times in a row. |
| Lightbulb - Brandon D | New Sweet Blueberries | 39th | 30A | Quit, attempting to bring Cat Bed back in the process. States that she quit due to being pressured by Flower. |
| Sunglasses - BFDIBOYERSFTW | New Sweet Blueberries | 38th | Involved in a flamewar on another camp | |
| Pen - Hunter Jaye | New Sweet Blueberries | 37th | Not as popular compared to the rest | |
| Cat Bed - Reviloja2 | N/A | Rejoins | 30A.5 | Nazrininator allowed him to rejoin, despite the fact that Lightbulb would have been amongst those who would have been eliminated anyway. |
| Milk - BOTIMaker1212 | Merge Contestant | (No place. Rejoins later) | 30B | Quits due to Controversy in BFMC |
| Asthma Inhaler - Ngradrian | Merge Contestant | 36th | 31A | Was possibly seen as a threat. Real reason unknown |
| Ice Cube - DarkSid3Gam3r | Merge Contestant | 35th | 32A | Possibly eliminated for being a threat or a debuter; It could be those reasons why Ice Cube was nearly eliminated in 30A. She was also eliminated because of Match's win token. |
| Needle - Jeelhu77 | Merge Contestant | 34th | 33A | Needle was eliminated due to being a threat, as she got 2nd in BFMT. |
| Pencil - Sumixam28 | Merge Contestant | 33rd | 34A | Not the most popular of users |
| Firey - smeltking | Merge Contestant | Debuts | 35A | Recieved the most votes to join. |
| Match - Ben1178 | Merge Contestant | 32nd | 35A | Possible Threat |
| Golf Ball - NickIt | Merge Contestant | (No Place. Becomes uneliminated) | 36A | Inactivity; Crayon's WT |
| Uneliminated | 36A Update | Naz found it unfair to eliminate a contestant up for re-signups. | ||
| Cat Bed - Reviloja2 | Merge Contestant | 31st | 37A | Cat Bed's rejoin was controversial (and caused the quit for rejoin technique to be permanently banned). Dusty's Reversal Token also caused Casey's Love Token on Cat Bed to make his dislikes infinite, and he had the least likes out of the people affected by the reversed love tokens, which caused Cat Bed to get obliterated, again. Dusty is sorry for what the RT caused. |
| Crayon - Objectdude73 | Merge Contestant | 30th | Dusty's Reversal Token caused Flower's Love Token to utterly annhilate Crayon, as she had the second least likes out of the people affected by the reversed love tokens. Dusty is sorry for what the RT caused. | |
| Flower - Retro Guy/SugarSpice115 | Merge Contestant | 29th | 38A | Flower's previous user, Retro, decided to quit to bring back BFMC. During #BFMC40Rejoin, she was put up for re-signups. |
| Milk - BOTIMaker1212 | Merge Contestant | Rejoins | 38A | Quit earlier; Decided to rejoin |
| Paper Airplane - ThatJRP14 | Merge Contestant | |||
| Reversal Token - KirbyRider1337 | Merge Contestant | |||
| Yin-Yang - Cpinkman3 | Merge Contestant | |||
| Woody - goldenzoomi | Merge Contestant | Debuts | Unfairly put up for re-signups. | |
| Firey - Smeltking | Merge Contestant | 28th | 39A | Randomly picked by Ruby's Kamikaze Token; Friends with Ruby; Debuter |
| Suitcase - RoboStartheBomb | Merge Contestant | 27th | Surprise Double Elimination | |
| Milk - BOTIMaker1212 | Merge Contestant | 26th | 40A | DNP |
| Soap Chex - Fizzy Jam | Merge Contestant | Rejoins | 40A | Got a very high score in the rejoin challenge; Popularity |
| Fly Swat - MatrVincent | Merge Contestant | Another contestant campaigned for him to rejoin; Popularity | ||
| Globe - SuperNinBFDI | Merge Contestant |
Got the second-most votes; As Lollipop's judgement on Soap Chex's challenge entry could be seen as unfair, she decided to let Globe back in as well. | ||
| Trikiesyl - XanyLeaves | Merge Contestant | Debuts | 40A | Xany is one of the most popular users in the object show community period. |
| Traffic Light - deedo886 | Merge Contestant | User Popularity; Lots of potential |